Cricinfo Mobile
Guest Column Guest ColumnRSS FeedFeeds  | Archives
Email Feedback Print

Obsolete and essential

South Africa may not really need Jacques Kallis' runs at the moment, but he is a long way from being dispensable just yet

Robert Houwing

December 9, 2008

Comments: 7 | Text size: A | A


Jacques Kallis finds himself in an odd position - in a slump, but not called on to play his customary sheet-anchor's role © Getty Images
 

Passenger? Now there's a funny thing.

Isn't Jacques Kallis more customarily the irreplaceable driver, in batting terms, of the Good Steam Engine South Africa? But the wheel turns fascinatingly and unpredictably in cricket. Yes, in recent times King Henry - Kallis's second name - has been ingloriously relegated to bit part in the production, if you like, of Test runs for the Proteas.

As the team he has represented with rare distinction in 125 Tests sets up camp in Perth for another series against fierce but near-hoodoo adversaries Australia, the 33-year-old's palpable lack of form ought to be a source of deep consternation.

Two or three years ago it would have been precisely that. Opponents knew that if they blasted through the No. 4 bedrock, a soft South African underbelly might not be far away. But things have gone full circle, as evidenced by the 2008 calendar year thus far: amidst South Africa's most settled top six since re-admission to the Test fold, the name of JH Kallis is the sole one not routinely up in lights.

Graeme Smith, Neil McKenzie and Hashim Amla have all gone voraciously past 1000 Test runs for the year, while Ashwell Prince has 900 on the nose and AB de Villiers 885, with two further opportunities (Perth and Melbourne) ahead to reach the mark before Auld Lang Syne. A lot of South Africans have been ripping the proverbial fox to shreds: almost surreally, Kallis is the hound labouring at the rear of the pack. He shows just 519 runs from 13 Tests and 20 innings this year, at 28.83.

What is wrong? An inevitable school of thought examines his age and suggests he's "in natural decline" or that "the eyes must be going". The ravages of time cannot be wished away, but it is hard to be convinced on those grounds when you consider that Kallis was no young buck in 2007 either - and that was his best ever year in Test-average terms (a giddy 86.42: 1210 runs in only nine Tests).

Does one go into age-related retreat so wretchedly quickly? You would think not. More plausible is the likelihood that, in this most intricate of sports, he has encountered some technical speed bumps; some issues to rudely tickle the walls of his famous "bubble".

Kallis' predecessor in South Africa's No. 4 position, Daryll Cullinan, subscribes to this view. He told the Cape Times recently that it was a question of balance: "At the point of delivery, his head seems to be outside the off stump, which is too far." Cullinan also believes Kallis will come right. "I often use Jacques as an example when I'm doing my clinics with kids… he's always had such a perfect technique. I know he'll turn the corner against the Aussies."

Some South Africans are fearful that Kallis' current vulnerabilities will be exposed by a resurgent Brett Lee, who tends to get a bee in his bonnet anyway when bowling to the resilient right-hander on Australian soil; there have been some riveting and occasionally tetchy duels.

But Kallis also has a solid Test record there, with 728 runs at almost 50, and two centuries, including his maiden one, in his 10th Test innings, at the MCG in 1997. He still counts that second-innings 101, against an attack that included both Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath, as possibly his most satisfying. It helped South Africa to stalemate safety at 273 for 7, after being set an improbable 381 to win.

Top Curve
Annus horribilis
  • Kallis' batting average of 28.83 in 2008 is his lowest in a calendar year in which he's played more than five Tests. His performance this year marks a contrast to 2007, where he averaged 86.42 - his best in a calendar year. He was also the leading run-getter in the world that year, with 1210 runs in nine Tests.
  • Kallis' slump in form in 2008 is significant as he has also failed against Bangladesh, averaging just 25.75 in four Tests against them. He didn't play a Test against Bangladesh in 2007.
  • The modes of dismissals reflect Kallis' struggles this year. He's been bowled seven times in 20 innings in 2008, as opposed to just once in 17 last year. He's been bowled on 41 occasions in his career - that's 23.03% of his overall dismissals; for 2008 that figure is much higher, at 38.8%.
  • Kallis played more away Tests this year than he did in 2007. Seven out of his nine Tests in 2007 were played at home, in which he averaged 65.75. His performance in the two away Tests, both in Pakistan, was even better - he made three centuries and a fifty, averaging 210.50. In contrast, he has played nine away Tests this year, managing just one century and a half-century, and averaging 24.78. He's done better at home, with an average of 43 in four Tests.
  • South Africa have a better win-loss record in 2008 and Kallis' travails have not affected them too adversely. He's averaged 44 in their nine wins, but just 6.75 in their two losses. In 2007, however, he averaged 93.77 in South Africa's six wins and 50 in their two defeats.
  • By Siddhartha Talya.
Bottom Curve

This writer's sixpence is that Kallis has suffered more from a crisis of identity in recent months than anything else. Strange as it may seem, the oft-rampant success of the Smith-McKenzie opening partnership, the perpetual advancement of Amla at No. 3 and the dogged durability of Prince one rung below Kallis has rendered the veteran's own long-time trench-fighting qualities virtually obsolete.

It is hardly an unwelcome phenomenon in terms of the Proteas' broad health and future prospects: where once Kallis would routinely set out his personal stall at 40 for 2, he has more recently tended to take guard with the total nearer 150 or 200 (or even well more) and the requirement much more to "get a crack on". And getting a crack on, as the world knows, is not his strongest suit. So he has possibly been feeling a little like long-distance running legend Haile Gebrselassie would if thrust into the field for the 200-metre dash: suddenly strangely out of place.

Batting in adversity is Kallis' forte, his party trick. A raft of younger players effectively hiding his magician's suitcase cheekily at the back of the dressing room is no sinister development, even if it may require him to tweak his own game plan to some degree.

Tweak it he should be urged to do - even his admirers' patience will have been tested by his particularly grim conservatism against limp Bangladesh, where his unremarkable 40 runs over two innings in the short series came at a painful strike-rate of 37.38. Poor nick as mitigation or not, the blunt truth is he "missed out".

Still, who's to say adversity won't revisit South Africa in Australia? History suggests that peril may well lurk for them there more than they would like, and the old firefighter will be summoned to his most relished responsibility once more.

He needs 199 runs and five wickets to become the first player to register both 10,000 runs and 250 wickets in Tests; Australia would be an apt place for Kallis to raise the milestone.

Woes with the blade or not, he remains a vital balancer in the South African team in his role as fourth seamer, where his "heavy ball" is still exactly that, by all accounts, and his ability to break partnerships or knock over pesky tailenders is barely dimmed. His general gnarly experience as a cricketer is also important for this series.

If Kallis is presently a sedentary passenger on the Proteas' batting train, nobody is begrudging him silver service and the finest cognac in the dining coach. Nobody, yet, wants him off at the next stop.

There are still many prongs to his arsenal, even if the main gun barrel is strangely muted.

Robert Houwing is chief writer for Sport24.co.za in South Africa

RSS Feeds: Robert Houwing
Comments: 7 
Email Feedback Print
Posted by JackJ on (December 10 2008, 22:22 PM GMT)

Jacques is the best SA cricketer since re-entry, without a shadow of doubt. At just a tad over 33, he is still at an age where top batsmen tend to be in their prime. No way that age has suddenly caught up with him! It just doesnt happen like that. There are 4 possible reasons for his loss of form. 1 Technical bugs that have crept into his game, possibly caused originally by an injury. It happens to the best. One of SA's duo of supergreats, Graeme Pollock, went through a lean period in the 70's. He tried specs and contacts but eventually threw them away and recovered form. 2 Something in his private life is awry. 3 Its well known that he and firm pal Bouch are not the favourites in the eyes of certain groups in SA. Some of these are in CSA and could be stirring. 4 Any of the above, compounded now by loss of confidence after a poor year with the bat. What he needs is an ace batting coach like Gary Kirsten. A few sessions with the videos will soon bring out any faults to work on.

Posted by morbidpixie on (December 09 2008, 21:38 PM GMT)

Kallis should show his strength in Australia. There's enough evidence to show that he can, but if he closes this year on a low, I doubt his selection would be automatic next year. SA cricket is in enough trouble with quota's etc. that they'd probably shove Loots Bosman in there as soon as there's a chance. I hope Kallis can prove all the doubters wrong and find those 5 wickets and 199 runs...

Posted by itzanurag on (December 09 2008, 17:40 PM GMT)

I find it, perhaps, the biggest irony that the two batsmen with the most immaculate techniques in contemporary cricket have so woefully fallen from grace. Perhaps, providence! Anyways, these two are the most astute servants of the game, unlike the Prince's and the Master's! Perhaps a reminder to the T20 generation that there is another "cricket" which exists, different from the cricket played by Sehwag, Gilchrist and Jayasuriya. Maybe less spectacular, but equally important nonetheless as it is the foundation given by them on which the beautiful edifices are built by the "other" kinds! The last link with an endangered( if not already extinct) generation of "defensive" cricketers! I sincerely wish both of them redeem one last time the understated glory of their careers!

Posted by gauravjn on (December 09 2008, 17:00 PM GMT)

ya, Kallis is going through a bad patch. It will just be a matter of time when he gets back into form. A note for the writer: please write shorter sentences. Some of your sentences form a paragraph itself making it unduly long to read and boring. thank you.

Posted by Proteas_no-1_Fan on (December 09 2008, 11:32 AM GMT)

Jaques Kallis is the best allrounder in the world at the moment.And he is ranked No-1 in ICC test allrounder rating.And he is among the top 20 players in both batting and bowling ratings.So no one can argue with his selection.Though he had a poor run with his batting he managed to coverup with his bowling performance this year.That shows how good allrounder he is.Even this year his batting average(28.83) is higher than his bowling average(27.04).Yes his batting average this year is very much below for his standards.The way he played last year was unbelievable and he won many series for proteas last year.After being dropped in T20 W/c He cameback and scored 420 runs in two mathes with the average of 210.So surely he can turnthings around in this important series against Australia.Proteas won some of the recent series without Kallis's major contribution but Proteas really wants Kallis to perform as he performed last year.I am sure Kallis will come back and Proteas will win the series.

Posted by sanvir_m on (December 09 2008, 10:41 AM GMT)

Kallis may not be contributing with the bat, but he has been in very good form with the ball recently, so I don't think he is danger of being dropped anytime soon.

Posted by nonplussed on (December 09 2008, 07:27 AM GMT)

Is this very close to what Dravid is going thru these days? Both play similar brand of cricket and both seem to afflicted with some mysterious virus " No runs". What say? Maybe they are just a touch late to get into position. They might probably need to train like Sylvestor stallone in "Rocky I " where he tries to catch a rooster. This might quicken their reflexes and the eye. :-)

Comments have now been closed for this article

Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Robert HouwingClose
Related Links

Sachin's mind is still strong Magazine

Ian Chappell: More than a decade after his exploits in Sharjah, Tendulkar has proved he still has the spirit of old

Rajasthan Royals win the first IPL Magazine

50 Magic Moments: With a wave of the wand, Warne takes his boys home

He who was the Golden Age Magazine

How Victor Trumper came to be an embodiment of a period, and an emblem for values his countryment still hold dear. By Gideon Haigh

'The Kolkata situation is one I'm used to' Magazine

The Knight Riders' new coach, Dav Whatmore, on the factors he will bank on to turn the team around

What's a reasonable winning score in ODIs?

It Figures - Analysing the scores over the years

  • Cricinfo Widgets
Sponsored Links

Access your Indian Rupee earnings from anywhere in the world.

Debate now on the new ESPN Soccernet Castrol Rankings Blog

at Cricshop

on www.f1-live.com

Bodyline

Bowl a fast one

Cricinfo Mobile Site

Our brand new mobile site

Slogout

Our classic simulation game