Email Feedback Print

Giving democracy the finger

Zimbabwe Cricket has finally abandoned any pretence of being democratic

Martin Williamson

November 10, 2007

Comments: 5 | Text size: A | A



Peter Chingoka: carry on regardless © Getty Images

At least Zimbabwe Cricket (ZC) have finally abandoned any pretence at being a representative, democratic institution. Like the regime it functions under, it has eschewed all but the charade of being accountable, and those running it have this week shown two fingers to the dwindling band inside the country who still care.

The news that the board's Annual General Meeting takes place this weekend only broke when Peter Chingoka's predecessor as chairman, Dave Ellman Brown, called the ZC offices and found out, during the course of a conversation, that he was no longer a life president. It then emerged that all such life appointees - honorary posts awarded for a lifetime of contributions to the game - had been stripped of their positions without even being notified.

On the face of it, this is a callous and cowardly move. It also is another blow to what remains of the tarnished reputation of Chingoka. As chairman this decision has to rest with him, yet even though he knows all of these appointees closely and has worked with them for years, he couldn't bring himself to face them and tell them in person why they had been treated so appallingly.

The real reason for the decision is clear when seen in connection with the AGM. It has traditionally been the one public forum where the board can be held to account, where officers can be questioned and where the finances can be scrutinised. In recent years it has been a fairly harrowing experience for the executive. But this year ZC has ruled that only delegates from the newly created provinces can attend. Strictly speaking, under the rules any presidents or vice presidents can also demand to be present. ZC has removed that potential embarrassment by taking them out of the equation.

So the AGM will be a farce. Only delegates from provinces created by the ZC board in 2006 will be present; and those appointed to run the regional boards were hand-picked acolytes. All dissenters and those whose faces did not fit were cleansed then. It was a cynical ploy to appease the international community and pretend there was a vibrant and democratic domestic set-up. There is as much chance of a delegate questioning the ZC executive on Saturday as there is of a Zanu PF conference asking Robert Mugabe to justify his economic policy.

It is clear that the accounts of ZC have been deliberately falsified to mask various illegal transactions from the auditors and the government of Zimbabwe.

ICC CEO Malcolm Speed in July Click here for his full quotes

What ZC fears most is that its accounts will be scrutinised internally. Already the ICC-appointed accountants have been sniffing round the books. In June, Malcolm Speed said that it was "clear that the accounts of ZC have been deliberately falsified to mask various illegal transactions". So no accounts have been circulated and it seems only the hand-picked will be privy to them at the AGM. Even so, what they get might not matter. As Speed said of previous offerings: "It may not be possible to rely on the authenticity of its balance sheet."

What this latest contemptuous move suggests is that ZC believes it has weathered the international storm and that it no longer needs to maintain the veneer of accountability. Chingoka is shrewd enough to know that other boards, and as a result the ICC, don't really care what happens. It's all about votes and behind-the-scenes deals. If Zimbabwe supports the right people when it matters, nobody will rock the boat.

Cricket limps on in the country, and despite Speed's reservations, ZC received US$11 million from the ICC in the last year and has nobody to account to about how that money is spent. It's a criminal reflection of the priorities of the modern game.

Martin Williamson is executive editor of Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: Martin Williamson
Comments: 5 
Email Feedback Print
Posted by batone on (November 16 2007, 19:22 PM GMT)

A few years ago there were a lot of respected administrators in Zimbabwe Cricket. They have all left due to no confidence in the system and due to grose mismanagement. Malcolm Speed this has all happened on your watch and you still sit there and do nothing!!! At least people like Daryl Hare make decisions based on how they interpret the law of cricket and you tarnish their image to protect the ICC. You Malcolm Speed make no decisions and continue to sit on the fence as a typical corporate, so called leader. You sit there in your ivory tower and judge players for bringing the game into disrepute. What is happening to cricket in Zimbabwe has brought the game into disrepute on a grosely larger scale than a player could ever do, now do something about it. Can you actually make a decision or are you waiting for someone else to make it for you?????

Posted by ronilove9 on (November 15 2007, 06:28 AM GMT)

we can all say a lot about corruption about the current board but i believe that we shouls only start talking when the auditing results come out, and as for the illegal forex dealings comon zimbabweans which one of you is exchanging their forex in the formal legal market, even some government departments are dealing in the black market coz everyone wants their value for their money,as for the restructuring i beleive we should see evil when we have sawn evil, not to just speculate that the restructuring was done to hide evil can the writer of this article sustantiate his claims or its the usaul hate gospel towards the zc board and gvt

Posted by murf on (November 14 2007, 08:52 AM GMT)

Time at last for the ICC to step up to the plate and justify its position as the governing body in World Cricket and refuse to acknowledge what is now openly an unconstituted Cricket administration in Zimbabwe.Also, the results of the forensic audit must be made public so that the cricket world is aware of the chicanery that has taken place under Chingoka and his cohorts.How much money has been pilfered and squandered to the detriment of cricket in Zimbabwe ???

Posted by nkosilathi on (November 13 2007, 22:01 PM GMT)

I am a Zimbabwean cricket supporter and it pains me to see the cricket in Zimbabwe being destroyed by two people,Ovias Bvute and Paul Chingoka. What are the people in ICC doing?I think they should intervene and force these two detactors to practice democracy and tranparency. I as a supporter have lost all respect for these people in ZCU. I wish someone could do something and help our cricket standard to improve. I also like to ask all our heroes STREAK,FRIEND,and all the guys who are still playing cricket in other countries to please reconsider and play cricket for Zimbabwe again. God bless you guys wish you all the best. cheers.

Posted by 4evaZim on (November 11 2007, 20:22 PM GMT)

A few years ago a lot of people , me included, would have been shocked by the news of the regular clandestine dealings of Zim Cricket Board . To say lm no longer amazed is an understatement ....how come they are able to fool all interested parties and carry on without any shame or remorse ? How can two people (Ozias Bvute and Peter Chingoka) be bigger than a national sport , hell an lnternational sport thats meant to be held in high regard ...its meant to be a gentleman's sport - not only on the field but in the boardroom there behind the Kegg and Maiden too. Mr Speed you lost my confidence during the time when Zim Cricket was torn to shreds by player revolt that cost Zimbabwe so much talent , l find it hard now to look at you and see in you an exemplary cricket Administrator

Comments have now been closed for this article

FeedbackTop
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Martin WilliamsonClose
Martin Williamson Executive editor Martin Williamson joined the Wisden website in its planning stages in 2001 after failing to make his millions in the internet boom when managing editor of Sportal. Before that he was in charge of Sky Sports Online and helped launch and run Sky News Online. With a preference for all things old (except his wife and children), he has recently confounded colleagues by displaying an uncharacteristic fondness for Twenty20 cricket. His enthusiasm for the game is sadly not matched by his ability, but he remains convinced that he might be a late developer and perseveres in the hope of an England call-up with his middle-order batting and non-spinning offbreaks. He is now managing editor of ESPN EMEA Digital Group as well as his Cricinfo responsibilities.
  • Cricinfo Widgets
Sponsored Links

Access your Indian Rupee earnings from anywhere in the world.

Debate now on the new ESPN Soccernet Castrol Rankings Blog

at Cricshop

on www.f1-live.com

Bodyline

Bowl a fast one

Cricinfo Mobile Site

Our brand new mobile site

Slogout

Our classic simulation game