Email Feedback Print

How visiting players have fared in the West Indies

Ponting's Caribbean rut, and economical Agarkar

This week we look at how visiting players have performed in the West Indies in one-day internationals and Tests; we're focussing on current players, many of whom will be at the World Cup

Travis Basevi and George Binoy

February 28, 2007

Text size: A | A



Ricky Ponting averages 98.71 in Tests but only 26.41 in ODIs in the West Indies © Getty Images

The World Cup starts in less than a fortnight in the Caribbean so the List finally decided to jump on the bandwagon and shift its focus towards the big bash. This week we look at how visiting players have performed in the West Indies in one-day internationals and Tests; we're looking at current players, many of whom will be at the World Cup.

England's 60 Tests in the West Indies and Australia's 30 ODIs there since 1978 are the highest for any touring team. Among the major title contenders, Sri Lanka are the least experienced, having played just four Tests and five ODIs in the West Indies. In fact there have been only two one-day tournaments involving more than two teams in the Caribbean. As a result, precious few players have hands-on experience of West Indian conditions going into the World Cup. And so we've set our qualifications to at least six innings over two series for batsmen, to rule out one-series wonders, and 300 balls over two series for bowlers.

Ricky Ponting, under pressure after Australia's recent slump, will want to answer critics in the manner he knows best - with his bat. As a batsman, his record in the Caribbean is two-faced. Ponting scored a hundred in his first Test in the West Indies and has since plundered 691 runs in nine innings at 98.71. On his last tour, he hit three consecutive centuries and bagged the Man-of-the-Series award. In ODIs, however, Ponting hasn't scored a hundred in 14 innings and averages only 26.41 with two half-centuries. He'll need to boost that if Australia are going to complete a World Cup hat-trick.

Biggest positive difference in average for overseas batsmen in West Indies - Tests (qualification: 6 innings, 2 series)
Player Span Mat Runs Ave 100 WI Runs Ave 100 Diff
SM Pollock (SA) 2001-2005 107 3781 32.31 2 6 315 78.75 1 46.433
RT Ponting (Aus) 1999-2003 110 9368 59.29 33 5 691 98.71 4 39.423
APE Knott (Eng) 1968-1974 95 4389 32.75 5 7 514 57.11 0 24.357
EH Hendren (Eng) 1930-1935 51 3525 47.63 7 8 895 68.84 2 21.211
L Hutton (Eng) 1948-1954 79 6971 56.67 19 7 848 77.09 2 20.416
SM Gavaskar (India) 1971-1983 125 10122 51.12 34 13 1404 70.20 7 19.078
NJ Astle (NZ) 1996-2002 81 4702 37.02 11 4 438 54.75 2 17.726
SR Waugh (Aus) 1991-2003 168 10927 51.06 32 14 1096 68.50 4 17.439
MC Cowdrey (Eng) 1960-1968 114 7624 44.06 22 10 1025 60.29 4 16.224
S Madan Lal (India) 1976-1983 39 1042 22.65 0 6 230 38.33 0 15.681

Click here for the ODI tables.

More than half of New Zealand's World Cup squad has never played in the Caribbean before and only Stephen Fleming has toured twice, which is why Nathan Astle's experience could be missed. He too has starkly different Test and ODI stats in the West Indies; his Test average of 54.75 overshadows his 24.11 in ODIs. Fleming's form will be crucial to New Zealand's success and his average of 43.77 is ranked tenth in our table of highest ODI averages in the Caribbean.

The batsman with the best average in the West Indies isn't even going to the World Cup. Boeta Dippenaar, often panned for his slow strike-rate, averages 107 in ODIs in the West Indies but was left out of South Africa's World Cup plans because of a recent rut. He toured in 2001 and 2005 and chalked up scored of 62*, 42*, 7, 56, 60*, 123, 17 and 61*.

Biggest positive difference in average for overseas batsmen in West Indies - ODIs (qualification: 6 innings, 2 series)
Player Span Mat Runs Ave 100 WI Runs Ave 100 Diff
HH Dippenaar (SA) 2001-2005 104 3344 42.87 4 10 428 107.00 1 64.128
V Sibanda (Zim) 2006-2006 46 1009 23.46 1 7 316 52.66 1 29.201
MG Bevan (Aus) 1999-2003 232 6912 53.58 6 12 367 73.40 0 19.818
CJ Chibhabha (Zim) 2006-2006 22 609 27.68 0 6 260 43.33 0 15.651
Inzamam-ul-Haq (Pak) 1993-2005 375 11665 39.67 10 14 590 53.63 0 13.959
SK Warne (Aus) 1995-1999 194 1018 13.05 0 11 106 26.50 0 13.448
HH Gibbs (SA) 2001-2005 198 6356 35.50 16 10 389 48.62 2 13.116
BRM Taylor (Zim) 2006-2006 60 1514 28.03 0 9 325 40.62 0 12.588
SP Fleming (NZ) 1996-2002 270 7684 32.15 7 10 394 43.77 1 11.627
NB Mahwire (Zim) 2006-2006 23 117 10.63 0 8 65 21.66 0 11.030

Click here for the Test tables.

Inzamam-ul-Haq has a splendid record in the West Indies but the two Ys that form the remainder of Pakistan's fulcrum have struggled. Mohammad Yousuf will want to carry on his sublime form over the last 14 months to the World Cup and improve his meagre collection of 190 in 10 ODIs in the West Indies. Younis Khan also has 190 runs but from nine innings at an average of 21.11.

Biggest negative difference in average for overseas batsmen in West Indies - ODIs (qualification: 6 innings, 2 series)
Player Span Mat Runs Ave 100 WI Runs Ave 100 Diff
Mohammad Yousuf (Pak) 2000-2005 233 7853 41.77 12 10 190 19.00 0 -22.771
DI Gower (Eng) 1981-1986 114 3170 30.77 7 6 55 9.16 0 -21.610
RT Ponting (Aus) 1995-2003 269 9856 42.48 22 14 317 26.41 0 -16.066
M Azharuddin (India) 1989-1997 334 9378 36.92 7 9 178 22.25 0 -14.671
Abdul Razzaq (Pak) 2000-2005 229 4449 30.06 2 10 127 15.87 0 -14.185
P Willey (Eng) 1981-1986 26 538 23.39 0 6 72 12.00 0 -11.391
NJ Astle (NZ) 1996-2002 223 7090 34.92 16 10 217 24.11 0 -10.814
Younis Khan (Pak) 2000-2005 148 3951 31.60 2 9 190 21.11 0 -10.496
RJ Shastri (India) 1983-1989 150 3108 29.04 4 7 130 18.57 0 -10.475
AJ Stewart (Eng) 1990-1998 170 4677 31.60 4 15 281 21.61 0 -9.986

Click here for the Test tables.

The bowlers will be keen to see how the new pitches will play in the West Indies - will they be the traditionally slow and low tracks or will belters be served up for the World Cup? This may come as a shock to some but Ajit Agarkar has the second best bowling average for a visiting bowler in the West Indies. He has 15 wickets in eight ODIs but the most eye-catching stat is Agarkar's economy-rate - 3.62 compared to his career 5.05.

Biggest difference in average for overseas bowlers in West Indies - ODIs (qualification: 300 balls, 2 series)
Player Span Mat Wkts Ave 5 WI Wkts Ave 5 Diff
P Utseya (Zim) 2006-2006 59 37 54.29 0 9 10 30.70 0 -23.597
Abdul Razzaq (Pak) 2000-2005 229 245 31.04 3 10 18 19.44 0 -11.600
NB Mahwire (Zim) 2006-2006 23 21 36.90 0 8 11 25.54 0 -11.359
AB Agarkar (India) 2002-2006 180 272 27.55 2 8 15 16.40 0 -11.151
A Nel (SA) 2001-2005 56 73 29.17 0 6 11 18.63 0 -10.541
CJ McDermott (Aus) 1991-1995 138 203 24.71 1 8 18 14.50 0 -10.219
ME Waugh (Aus) 1991-1999 244 85 34.56 1 16 13 25.00 0 -9.564
JH Kallis (SA) 2001-2005 247 225 31.01 2 11 12 22.08 0 -8.934
T Mupariwa (Zim) 2006-2006 19 33 26.21 0 7 15 18.20 0 -8.012
Mushtaq Ahmed (Pak) 1993-2000 144 161 33.29 1 9 11 26.72 0 -6.570

Click here for the Test tables.

India chose Harbhajan Singh and Anil Kumble as their specialist spinners over Ramesh Powar in their World Cup squad. Harbhajan Singh's worst record in any country is in the West Indies, where he has only six wickets in eight ODIs at a strike-rate of 70.

With Brett Lee out of the World Cup and the younger tearaways getting caned in New Zealand, extra pressure falls on the ageing shoulders of Glenn McGrath who also hasn't had much success in the West Indies. It is one of his least successful venues - just 10 wickets from 11 matches, which includes a four-wicket haul, at a strike-rate of 53.6. Australia's title defence will hinge on how he leads the attack.

Travis Basevi is the man who built Statsguru. George Binoy is editorial assistant of Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: George Binoy
Email Feedback Print
FeedbackTop
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
George BinoyClose
George Binoy Senior sub-editor After a major in Economics and nine months at a financial research firm, George realised that equity, capital and the like were not for him. He decided that he wanted to be one of those lucky few who do what they love at work. Alas, his prodigious talent was never spotted and he had to reconcile himself to the fact that he would never earn his money playing cricket for his country, state or even district. He jumped at the opportunity to work for Cricinfo and is now confident of mastering the art of office cricket.
  • Twenty years of Tendulkar
Sponsored Links

Access your Indian Rupee earnings from anywhere in the world.

Debate now on the new ESPN Soccernet Castrol Rankings Blog

Cricshop.com - leading online cricket store

on www.scrum.com

20 Years of Tendulkar

Cricinfo celebrates two decades of the maestro

Bodyline

Bowl a fast one

Cricinfo Mobile Site

Our brand new mobile site