'Australia, South Africa have best attacks'

Australia and South Africa have the best bowling attacks in world cricket today, with Pakistan, led by Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir, and England not too far behind, according to Ian Chappell, Allan Donald and Sanjay Manjrekar. Speaking on the latest episode of Time Out, they also agreed that India and Sri Lanka didn't measure up to the rest.

Among the parameters used to rate the line-ups was their effectiveness in all conditions. The ability of Australia and South Africa's bowlers to challenge batsmen on placid surfaces gave them an edge over the others, said Manjrekar. "When you look at bowling attacks from around the world Australia will still perhaps be No.1, because you can imagine that attack being pretty good on Indian conditions, in Sri Lanka as well," he said.

"Getting everything in the air, trying to beat batsmen in pace and not using the surface at all by bowling the ball full - that's where Australia are good. They have got Mitchell Johnson who uses the length well. Doug Bollinger is also quite happy pitching the ball up. Australia and South Africa to me are the attacks that can perhaps make an impression in all sorts of conditions."

England, with a strong pace attack and a successful spinner in Graeme Swann, Donald said, were formidable in home conditions. But he felt they would be tested in Australia later in the year. "It'll be very interesting for them to go to Australia during the Ashes and bowl on those flat pitches," Donald said. "With the new ball, they're pretty good. James Anderson is the bowler for me who really stands out in that regard. Stuart Broad is pretty much a line bowler, he's quite aggressive. But in conditions with the Kookaburra ball, they're going to need something off the deck as well. So they're going to be tested during the Ashes."

The success of the Pakistan seamers in England would have earned them more points among the experts had it not been for some poor catching and a "horrible" slip cordon. "You never know what you are going to get from Kamran Akmal, some days he has got bricks in his gloves. So that makes it very hard for the bowlers, when sometimes you have to get the guy out three times," Chappell said.

Donald rated Dale Steyn as the best fast bowler in the world, though Chappell had his doubts. "There was a classic example when Phil Hughes got his hundred in Durban. Steyn did not go after him, after Hughes at all until he got the hundred. I was starting to wonder when you had a handicap in Test cricket where they let you get a hundred before they get after you. So that's my query with Steyn. When he is good, he is very good; but he is a little bit moody."

The uncertainty with Zaheer Khan and Harbhajan Singh's lack of form in the recent past meant India were among the bottom-placed teams while Sri Lanka had much to thank Lasith Malinga for. "These are the sides that will struggle bowling people out," Donald said.