Legends of Cricket
StateFarm

Pakistan in Australia 2009-10

Twenty20 will 'finish' Pakistan cricket - Mohammad Yousuf

Osman Samiuddin in Melbourne

December 31, 2009

Comments: 127 | Text size: A | A
Mohammad Yousuf drives during his innings of 23, Pakistan v West Indies, Champions Trophy, Group A, Johannesburg, September 23, 2009
Too much Twenty20 cricket, Mohammad Yousuf has said, has affected the failure of the current players in the Pakistan team to adapt to the longer versions © Getty Images
Enlarge
Related Links

Mohammad Yousuf has issued a stark warning of the impending dangers of too much Twenty20 cricket, insisting that it is "necessary" that Pakistan plays as little of the format as possible. Otherwise, the Pakistan captain told Cricinfo, he believes the format will "finish Pakistan's cricket."

Yousuf's counsel comes in the wake of Pakistan's defeat to Australia in the first Test in Melbourne, where their batsmen struggled on a placid pitch in a 170-run loss. Australia declared twice in the Test, but Pakistan were bowled out for 258 and 251 - the second after being 170-3. But his words come in a broader context: those totals continued a long run of sub-par performances by the batsmen in the Test arena; in 14 Test innings now, they have crossed 350 only twice.

They have struggled with their openers and their No.3 batsmen, and have been caught in a number of Test collapses through the year in Sri Lanka, New Zealand and now Australia. As in Melbourne, a number of batsmen have settled in, before getting themselves out. The failure, Yousuf believes, comes from Twenty20 cricket.

"It [batting failures] used to happen before but now because of Twenty20 cricket no player knows how to stay at the wicket anymore," Yousuf told Cricinfo. "Batsmen are finding it very difficult. I know the format has money, players get it and boards do but if Pakistan hypes up Twenty20 too much, Test and ODI cricket will really go down."

Pakistan are the reigning world champions in the format, having won the World Twenty20 in a stirring display in June in England. They reached the final of the inaugural World Twenty20 in 2007 and have the best win-loss ratio of all nations in the format. In Umar Gul, Saeed Ajmal, Shahid Afridi and Abdul Razzaq they have, arguably, the format's sharpest game-changers.

They were also one of the first countries to adopt the format domestically, holding wildly successful events in Lahore and Karachi in 2005 and 2006, and the first three years of the tournament attracted what many believed to be the largest domestic crowds ever in Pakistan. Additionally, a number of their players had successful first seasons with the IPL; they weren't allowed to participate in tournament's second edition, but a number of them are very keen to be involved next season and over 12 players have applied for a place in the auction. Afridi, Rana Naved-ul-Hasan, Gul and Sohail Tanvir have all played, or are playing Twenty20 cricket, for Australian state sides as well.

MS Dhoni's response

  • It is quite similar to the review system (UDRS). If the decisions are in your favour, you are okay with it, but when they go against you, you don't really feel it is working. It is the same case with the Twenty20 format. I don't think it would be great to blame the format. It is a mental approach that needs to change. The change of mindset is important. The basics remain the same.

Most Pakistanis are brought up on a diet of 20-over cricket at club and street level. That, Yousuf believes, has left much of the current crop unsuited to the longer, unique demands of Test cricket and even ODI cricket. "Both in Tests and ODIs we have problems," Yousuf said. "We struggle to bat 50 overs. Against New Zealand [in Abu Dhabi] we couldn't make 212 in 50 overs. Everyone played shots and got out.

"Twenty20 is easy for Pakistanis because they know how to hit, nobody knows how to defend. Until players do not play with discipline and play ball to ball and leave balls they are supposed to we will struggle in ODIs, let alone Tests. If you see a ball, hit it because you have to score. But if you are going to slog all the time what is the point? I could have hit jumping out but unless you get a ball to hit what is the point? That is the point of Test cricket. It is necessary that Pakistanis, the media, the board, the fans realise that we play as little Twenty20 as possible.

"One domestic tournament is enough and a World Cup apart from that, but my belief is that you have to reduce Twenty20 heavily. They shouldn't play it in club cricket - even there you play 20 overs, not 40-over matches. I only have 2-3 years left in my career but I worry Twenty20 will finish Pakistan's cricket."

Yousuf himself has a strained relationship with the format. He was incensed at being dropped from Pakistan's squad for the inaugural World Twenty20 in 2007 in South Africa. Having criticized the selectors for not picking him, he aligned himself with the ICL, before being lured back into the Pakistan fold by the board. But once he was overlooked for another multi-nation Twenty20 tournament in Toronto in August 2008, he signed up with the ICL again, playing a few unsuccessful games for the Lahore Badshahs, before finally quitting and coming back to the Pakistan side earlier this year.

Alongside Younis Khan, Yousuf has been Pakistan's most reliable and successful Test batsman during and after the Inzamam-ul-Haq era. And with Younis and Javed Miandad, he is the only Pakistan batsman with a 50-plus Test average. His worries are the pre-eminent factor behind his request for Younis on this tour, though authorities in Pakistan have yet to accede to that.

"You look at England, South Africa and Australia. They give Test cricket and ODIs the attention they deserve," Yousuf said. "Until we do the same, we will not progress. They also play Twenty20 but they do it in a controlled way. In our country we only want to play Twenty20 and no Tests. I think we have given up on Test cricket: either we look for the money or we look to revive Pakistan cricket."

Osman Samiuddin is Pakistan editor of Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: Osman Samiuddin

© ESPN EMEA Ltd.

Comments: 127 
Posted by yasirmurad on (January 03 2010, 14:00 PM GMT)

I think if we have 12 good players, 8 of them can be used in all formats. Cricket is cricket. If you do not agree see Sehwag, jayasuriya or Gayle. They make a lot of runs in test cricket. That is why I would prefer Imran nazir on the current two and try to improve his skills. Cricket is about making more runs than your opposition.

Posted by wanderer1 on (January 03 2010, 09:07 AM GMT)

I find it hilarious that people are saying we're a joke and waste our talent. We're World T20 champions, which was supposedly the holy grail for Indians until they realised their Indian team was only half decent at T20 cricket, and now it's all about Test Matches. The same thing is happening in ODI cricket. Funny how people always twist what they deem is "success" to closely match where there team is doing best in at that moment. Aus are just as bad, deeming the Champions Trophy a joke but now they're champions, suddenly it's a big tournament and a big victory that matters. 2009 for Pakistani Cricket by and large wasn't that much worse than most other teams, we just had bigger highs and lows than the others.

Posted by khmayecha on (January 02 2010, 18:09 PM GMT)

I dont see any reason for such lame excuses. In fact, Pakistan cricket itself has become an excuse.....and an embarassment. A pitiable example of wasting away abundant talent.

Posted by Bang_La on (January 02 2010, 03:55 AM GMT)

What pakistan cricket? Wasnt it finished already, if there was any? :)

Posted by ejsiddiqui on (January 01 2010, 19:38 PM GMT)

Yousaf is missing a fact that, it is not abundance of t20 cricket but lack of test cricket causing Pakistani batsmen not to stay on wicket. Good players are performing well in both forms of the game. Lest compare Pakistan test team with t20 winning team. Yousaf, Farhat, Faisal, Salman, Rauf , Kaneria are not 20 players but also have not done good in test matches (with the exception of Kaneria). M. Aamer, Umar Akmal, Kamran Akmal are part of t20 winning team and are also doing good in test. So, this is not the case that t20 cricket is causing the problem. It is the quality of players and lack of cricket causing the problem. Although we have many different players in t20 format e.g. Imran Nazir, Navid ul Hasan, Abdur Razzaq, Shahid Afridi e.t.c The main thing is that, every format has its own uniqueness and importance. We should have players for every format.

Posted by Anneeq on (January 01 2010, 18:04 PM GMT)

The guy who sold his country out for the T20 ICL riches now looks back and says T20 is ruining Pk cricket, what a load of cobblers!! If the Pk players really were in T20 mode we would have seen international standard fielding and not pub team standard fielding. We would have seen a way higher scoring rate, in the first innings they scored at bwt 2 an over, thats not test standard never mind T20!! They should have infact taken more a T20 mindset and ATTACK at the Australians. It was quite upsetting seeing the lack of aggression and flare shown by the Pk players, they really dont understand that they are far far far more talented than the hosts! To me its all in the head, they have to want to smash the Aussies, not to just put up a tidy performance against them. The Pakistani players need to realise this is a very average Australian team, they played them with fear just like they used to in the McGrath and Warne days. You do that with any team, ur asking to lose!

Posted by faisalnoor70 on (January 01 2010, 17:53 PM GMT)

In my opinion, Yousuf istelling his team mates that its a shame that you guys are not performing as test batsmen. He does not want it to say directly, it is similar message that Younis gave to Pak team in T20 last year before the team turned it on. May be Yusuf is hoping that these demoralising comments could spur the team on to prove themselves in tests as well. On the point that t20 should be curtailed, I dont think it will happen because that is where the cash is whether Yusuf likes it or not. Today most people have forgotten the ethics or the norms in trying to make money for twenty life spans. Look at bollywood actors, they are just dropping their pants if shown cash, for example, you could make them dance in your wedding or kid's birthday if you have the money to pay them. Similarly who cares if Test criket is the real cricket, show me the money is the mantra of today's cricketers. Cricketers are careers are even shorter than actors, so they want to rack in as much as possibl

Posted by atuljain1969 on (January 01 2010, 10:31 AM GMT)

I enjoy pakistan cricket beacuse of the variety it showcases. Youth has played an imp. role their cricket. Exciting players like, Imran,Qadir,Azim Hafiz,Moin Khan,Inzmam,M.Amir etc have ensured that they always have someting fesh to offer. I agree with Yousuf, but may be PCB is inclined for No.1 position in 20-20. Really, if they want to promote Test cricket, they need to play more of longer version in their domestic set up, but with good remuneration otherwise players will go for 20-20. Like in India, Players now earn good money playing longer version, even if not selected for Indian colors they can make a living. You Board needs to divert money earned from 20-20 to longer version. Once this happen you will get better players. Morever we need to dismantle this belief that a good player will do well in all the formats. One needs specialisation in every format, hence separate teams i.e., not necassarily 100%. In S.Africa they even have separate captains for each version.

Posted by waqaswali on (January 01 2010, 10:24 AM GMT)

Mohd. Yousuf is absolutely correct, the most recent example is that, Shahid Afridi is currently playing T20 county cricket in Australia these days (n scoring well) on the other hand Our country lost the 1st Test at MCG, this shows that how much he gives importance to DOLLARS and how much importance he gives to PAKISTAN. This is all b'coz of some dollars....!!! Shame on u Mr. Shahid Afridi. We must avoid playing T20 format as much as possible, otherwise we will lose Class of Cricket. TRUE CRICKET IS five glorious day format, i.e. TEST CRICKET.

Posted by rajibhasan on (January 01 2010, 09:41 AM GMT)

i do agree with Yousuf. its not only about the player, i have also concern about spectator. u can find how T20 affected Test cricket by the number of spectator. from the second day of Boxing Day test, MCG gallery was almost empty. on the other hand T20 big bash was houseful!

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Osman SamiuddinClose
Osman Samiuddin Pakistan editor Osman spent the first half of his life pretending he discovered reverse swing with a tennis ball half-covered with electrical tape. The second half of his life was spent trying, and failing, to find spiritual fulfillment in the world of Pakistani advertising and marketing. The third half of his life will be devoted to convincing people that he did discover reverse swing. And occasionally writing about cricket. And learning mathematics.
Tour Results
Australia v Pakistan at Melbourne - Feb 5
Australia won by 2 runs
Australia v Pakistan at Perth - Jan 31
Australia won by 2 wickets (with 4 balls remaining)
Australia v Pakistan at Perth - Jan 29
Australia won by 135 runs
Australia v Pakistan at Adelaide - Jan 26
Australia won by 40 runs
Australia v Pakistan at Sydney - Jan 24
Australia won by 140 runs
More results »
  • ESPN Cricinfo
Sponsored Links

ICICI Money2India

Play Lufthansa Fantasy Cricket and other games!

Buy now at Cricshop.com - leading online cricket store

Buy now at Cricshop.com - leading online cricket store

Access your Indian Rupee earnings from anywhere in the world.